Who says neither can live while the other survives?

Who says neither can live while the other survives?

That is why we see in Snape’s memory Dumbledore telling Snape that Harry must die in order for Voldemort to be vulnerable—and Harry does die, he just merely returns. “Neither can live whilst the other survives” only means that one of them has to die, in order for the other to live.

What does the prophecy mean in Harry Potter?

You may be looking for the the specific prophecy regarding Lord Voldemort and Harry Potter or the device used to record Prophecies. The prophecy that altered Harry’s life forever. A prophecy was a prediction made by a Seer — someone with the ability to see into the future.

How did Snape know about the prophecy?

We know Snape did hear “born as the seventh month dies” because that was part of what made Voldemort decide the prophecy referred to Harry. It is likely, therefore, that Snape didn’t get any further than “… seventh month dies.” So what he heard was: “The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches …

Is the prophecy about Neville?

So in the books Harry Potter is indeed the chosen one, but in the films the rightful title goes to Neville Longbottom. He was born at the end of July, his parents were decommissioned by one of Voldemort’s people, he found the prophecy, and he is directly responsible for Voldemort’s death and not Harry in the films.

What if Voldemort chose Neville?

If Neville Had Been The Chosen One, he would have made Herbology as cool as Quidditch. If Neville Had Been The Chosen One, he still would have defeated Voldemort in his first and second year at Hogwarts because getting through all of that pretty much came down to blind luck and Hermione’s logic for Harry.

Is Sirius Black good or bad?

Sirius Black was Harry Potter’s godfather and a good man, but he definitely had his occasional problematic moments. Sirius is a character who’s portrayed to be a murdering convict, broken free of Azkaban to attack and kill his godson.

Is it true that neither can live while the other survives?

“Neither can live while the other survives” could also less literally be taken to mean that neither would rest until the other was defeated, which is certainly true of both Harry and Voldemort. –RP We were unable to load Disqus Recommendations.

When does Voldemort say neither can live while the other survives?

Neither can live while the other (the Horcrux) survives. When Voldemort kills the Horcrux inside Harry, he sees it under the bench crying at King’s Cross station in his limbo, when that one would be dead both of them can die or live, depending on the final duel.

Is the sentence ” neither can live while the other survives ” two statements?

The sentence is not two statements: “neither can live; while the other survives,” (“neither can live” means they both die, and “while the other survives” means that one lives), but rather the second half of the sentence is a condition for the first half: “while one survives, the other can’t live.”